Broward County Banner
ArrowCommission MeetingsArrowTerms of Use LightbulbAgenda Tips
Meeting Agendas

Print Back to Calendar Return
AI- 26132   45.    
Broward County Commission Regular Meeting
Meeting Date: 01/23/2018  
Director's Name: Andrew J. Meyers
Department: County Attorney  

Requested Action
MOTION TO SELECT from the list of four law firm teams as described and identified below, outside counsel to represent the County in connection with the opioid epidemic litigation, and to authorize and direct the County Attorney to negotiate and enter into a contract on behalf of the County with the selected law firm team on terms consistent with those outlined below.

ACTION:  (T-10:32 AM)  The Board approved selection of the First Ranked Team, as outlined in the Yellow-Sheeted Additional Material, dated Tuesday, January 23, 2018, submitted at the request of the Office of the County Attorney.  In addition, the Board permitted the County Attorney to add additional firms if needed.  (Refer to minutes for full discussion.)
VOTE: 6-2.  Commissioners Geller and Ryan voted no.  Vice-Mayor Bogen was not present.
Why Action is Necessary
On December 12, the Board of County Commissioners (the "Board") directed the County Attorney to bring forward for the Board's subsequent consideration a ranked list of up to four outside counsel teams.
What Action Accomplishes
Selects the outside law firm team to serve as the County's lead counsel in this matter.
Is this Action Goal Related
Previous Action Taken
Summary Explanation/Background
At its December 12 meeting, the Board authorized the filing of litigation against manufacturers, distributors, and other potential parties in connection with the opioid epidemic. The Board further directed the County Attorney to shortlist and rank up to four outside law firm teams from which the Board would choose the County's outside counsel.
Before the December 12 meeting, the County Attorney and Senior Assistant County Attorney Angela Benjamin had met with nine highly qualified teams of law firms seeking to represent the County. One of those teams subsequently withdrew. After receiving the Board's direction on December 12, the County Attorney and Ms. Benjamin met in the sunshine with three additional highly qualified teams.
Having completed all due diligence deemed necessary, the County Attorney hereby presents to the Board the following unranked shortlist of legal teams (presented in alphabetical order based on the name of the lead proposing firm):
  • Kopelowitz Ostrow Ferguson Weiselberg Gilbert; Morgan & Morgan; and Haliczer Pettis & Schwamm.
  • Lieff Cabraser Heimann & Bernstein; and Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP.
  • Motley Rice LLC; Gelber Schachter & Greenberg, P.A.; and Colson Hicks Eidson.
  • Simmons Hanly Conroy; Crueger Dickinson; and von Briesen & Roper, S.C.
Because of the stated importance of participation by local firms and by a diverse group of attorneys, and due to the fluid nature of each legal team’s potential composition, the County Attorney is delaying ranking the four shortlisted teams until no later than January 19 to provide the shortlisted teams with the opportunity to enhance the diversity and local presence of their proposed teams. The composition of some or all of the shortlisted teams may, therefore, change before January 19.
The ranking will be submitted to the Board (and distributed as additional material) on or before January 19.  Please remember that a two-way cone of silence remains in effect until the ranking is submitted. All of the legal teams with which we have met will be reminded of the cone of silence. Additionally, each of the shortlisted teams has confirmed that representatives from the team are available to make a short presentation to the Board at the Board's January 23 meeting.
The Board had previously directed that this matter be brought for the Board’s consideration on January 9.  However, in a December 14 memorandum, the County Attorney advised the Board that the federal court presiding over the multidistrict litigation ("MDL") had scheduled an in-person conference for January 9 on the topic of MDL leadership.  Although the January 9 conference proceeded for other reasons, on January 4 the federal court approved the plaintiffs' MDL leadership slate.  Each of the shortlisted teams (and others that were not shortlisted) is currently represented among the MDL's leadership.
Any contract with outside counsel will include the following mandatory terms: (1) a contingency fee arrangement in which the team would receive a maximum of 25% of the net recovery received by the County; (2) the team would advance all costs and expenses of the litigation and agree that the County is only obligated to reimburse such costs or expenses out of any financial recovery; (3) litigation costs and expenses would be equitably divided among any and all plaintiffs represented by the team (i.e., among all governmental entities represented by the same team or its constituent members in opioid epidemic litigation) (in addition, we would seek to negotiate a cap on these costs and expenses); and (4) if the team (or any member of the team) contracts to represent a local governmental entity in opioid epidemic litigation at a lower contingency fee or a lower cap on costs (if applicable), or if such contract more narrowly defines the recoveries to which the contingency fee would apply, the County's financial obligation would automatically be reduced to match that term (i.e., a "most favored nations" clause).
Source of Additional Information
Angela F. Benjamin, Senior Assistant County Attorney, (954) 357-7600

Fiscal Impact
Fiscal Impact/Cost Summary:
There is no immediate fiscal impact, as fees and costs for outside counsel will be paid only from the financial recovery, if any, to the County. Significant coordination will, however, be required among outside counsel, members of the County Attorney's Office, and County staff members who can provide information helpful to development of the County's lawsuit.
Additional Material - Information

AgendaQuick©2005 - 2019 Destiny Software Inc., All Rights Reserved